
A buyer pays a Chinese factory to develop a new product. It sells well. Two years later, he tries to move production — and learns three things in one afternoon: the drawings live in the factory's CAD system, the patent application carries the factory's name, and the molds stay with the factory until "outstanding balances" clear.
None of that is bad luck. It is the default rule under Chinese law.
When your contract is silent, the law fills in the blanks — and almost every default moves ownership away from the party who paid, and toward the party who holds the asset: the developer, the designer, or the factory floor.
Here is what buyers assume, versus what the law actually says:
- You assume: "I paid for the development, so the patent is mine."
The law says: The developer gets the patent application right (Civil Code, Art. 859). - You assume: "The know-how is mine — I funded it."
The law says: Both sides may use it and transfer it (Civil Code, Art. 861). - You assume: "The design files are mine — I paid the designer."
The law says: Copyright follows the person who created them (Copyright Law, Art. 19). - You assume: "I paid for the molds, so I own them."
The law says: There is no rule at all. Whoever holds the metal, keeps the metal.
Don't rely on trade secret law to rescue you after the fact. The Anti-Unfair Competition Law requires you to prove you took confidentiality measures. Emailing drawings to a factory without signing anything usually fails that test.
The takeaway: You cannot rely on verbal agreements or purchase orders. You need four specific documents to close these gaps: an NNN agreement, a development contract, a mold clause, and your own Chinese registrations. We will break down each one in this series.
No comments:
Post a Comment