400 Refunds, Zero Returns: How a Xi'an Woman Gamed Hema's Refund Policy — and Got Detained

A 29-year-old woman in Xi'an has been criminally detained on suspicion of fraud after allegedly filing more than 400 "refund-only" claims with Hema over three years — keeping the groceries, and the refunds too. Police put the total at more than RMB 17,000 (about US$2,400).

According to a bulletin released by Xi'an police on November 17, the woman — identified in Chinese media only by her surname, Yu — said the refunds gave her a thrill and helped her cope with the stress of preparing for China's postgraduate entrance exams, the notoriously competitive kaoyan. She had been studying at home for years, failing the exam again and again.

The detained woman, face blurred, stands between two police officers outside the Weiyang District Detention Center in Xi'an

How "Refund-Only" Works — and How It Was Allegedly Abused

If you shop online in China, you have probably seen the "refund-only" option (仅退款). For eligible orders, a customer who reports a problem — say, food that arrived spoiled — can get their money back without sending anything back. It is meant to protect shoppers from bad goods. Police say this woman turned it into a way to shop for free.

Hema staff contacted Zhangjiabao Police Station in early November after an internal review flagged one customer's account. She had been placing orders almost daily since 2023, and more than 400 of them ended in refund-only requests. The reasons were strikingly similar every time: the food supposedly tasted bad or wasn't fresh. But nothing was ever returned, and when staff tried calling her, they couldn't get through.

New Numbers, New Addresses — the Same Pattern

Investigators compared order histories, refunds, delivery records, and recipient details. Although her phone numbers and delivery addresses changed frequently, the timing, product categories, and refund patterns stayed remarkably consistent.

Police say it started in 2023, when she discovered the refund option after ordering snacks. The first successful claim worked — and whenever she felt frustrated after that, she did it again. The orders grew from snacks and drinks to everyday household supplies. When repeated violations got her blocked from ordering through the Hema app, she simply switched to Hema stores on other shopping platforms and carried on. She told investigators she kept choosing Hema because she liked the quality of its products.

What Police Found at Her Home

On November 5, officers came to her home — and arrested her there. Snacks and household products were piled up in the living room and beside the bed. Some had been partly eaten; others were still unopened.

Groceries and household supplies stockpiled at the woman's home, including drinks, snacks, and tissues

According to her statement to police, she knew the claims were wrong and felt uneasy every time she made one. But when a refund went through, the temptation to try again won out.

What Happens Next

Police say the alleged use of made-up complaints to obtain goods met the threshold for a criminal investigation. She has been criminally detained on suspicion of fraud — meaning she is being held while the investigation continues, not that she has been convicted of anything. No court verdict has been announced, and the case remains under investigation. Chinese media report that she has confessed and accepted the penalty.

Police also issued a reminder that is worth remembering for anyone shopping in China: "refund-only" is a consumer-protection service with clear conditions. It is not a loophole for free groceries. Used honestly, it is one of the most shopper-friendly rules in Chinese e-commerce; abused at scale, it can cross the line from a customer-service dispute into a criminal case.

Source: Xi'an police bulletin of November 17, as reported by The Paper.

No comments:

Post a Comment