400 Orders, Zero Yuan Paid: Xi'an Woman Arrested for Abusing Hema's 'Refund Without Return' Policy

She ordered snacks worth just a few dozen yuan each time. Over three years, she placed more than 400 orders — without paying a single penny.

On November 17, police in Xi'an reported that a 29-year-old woman had exploited Hema's "refund without return" policy to get groceries for free. The total value exceeded 17,000 yuan (around $2,400). She has since been taken into criminal custody on suspicion of fraud.

According to the Xi'an Economic Development Zone police, the case began in early November, when staff at a Hema store noticed something odd about one customer's account. Since 2023, the woman had been ordering almost every day — and more than 400 of those orders had ended with a "refund only" request. The reasons were nearly always the same: the food "tasted bad" or "wasn't fresh." The goods, however, were never sent back.

The woman, surnamed Yu, had been studying at home for China's postgraduate entrance exam, retaking it year after year without passing. Under mounting stress, she stumbled on the loophole in 2023: pick a particular refund reason after receiving a snack order, and the money came back while the snacks stayed. She later told police the rush felt "exciting" — and that it eased her stress.

After that first successful refund, it became a habit. Whenever she felt anxious, she would order snacks, drinks, and daily necessities, then file for a refund. Over three years, she placed more than 400 such orders — roughly one every three days — covering almost everything she needed day to day.

To avoid detection, she frequently changed phone numbers and delivery addresses, split her orders into smaller ones, and moved to Hema stores on other e-commerce platforms when her accounts were restricted.

The scheme came to light after Hema staff flagged the unusual transaction patterns and called the police. On November 5, officers visited her home and found the living room and bedroom piled high with Hema snacks and household goods. Some had been half-eaten; many were still unopened.

Some of the Hema products found at the woman's home

Some of the Hema products found at the woman's home. Image source: Xi'an Police

The woman admitted she knew what she was doing was wrong, and that she felt uneasy every time — but the belief that she would not get caught kept her going. She also said she chose Hema because she trusted the quality of its products.

China's "refund without return" policy exists to protect shoppers — for fresh food and fast-moving goods, sending items back is often impractical, so a refund without a return settles genuine disputes quickly. It was never meant to be a way to get free goods. Under Chinese law, fraud involving 3,000 yuan or more can carry a sentence of up to three years in prison, criminal detention, or restricted liberty, along with a fine.

Exam stress is no excuse for fraud. There are many ways to relieve stress, but breaking the law should never be one of them.

Source: Xi'an Police (via The Paper / Hualong Net)

No comments:

Post a Comment