
A Ghanaian man working in Shenzhen spent more than six months trying to recover his ¥16,000 rental deposit after moving out of an apartment in Qianhai. Despite completing the handover without incident, he was left caught in a dispute among three people, each of whom pointed to someone else as being responsible for returning the money.
How the Deposit Ended Up in Three Hands
Mr. Blake (pseudonym), a Ghanaian national who has long worked and lived in Shenzhen, signed a one-year rental agreement with a man surnamed Wang in May 2025. The monthly rent was ¥8,000, and he transferred a ¥16,000 deposit to an account belonging to a person surnamed Li, as instructed by Wang.
Throughout the tenancy, Blake also followed Wang's instructions to pay the monthly rent of ¥8,000 to a third person, surnamed Zhang.
The arrangement appeared to work without problems until the lease expired and Blake moved out.
The Move-Out: Nobody Had the Money
On the day of the move-out, Blake and Zhang completed the property handover. Blake then asked for his deposit back, only to be told by Zhang that the money had not been paid to him.
"The deposit was collected by Wang, and the money is in Li's account. They should return it," Zhang reportedly said.
With Wang, Li and Zhang each involved in different parts of the rental arrangement, responsibility for the ¥16,000 deposit became a point of contention. Rather than receiving his money, Blake found himself caught in a dispute among the three, with each pointing elsewhere over who should bear the repayment obligation.
Three Defendants, No One Willing to Take Responsibility
After more than six months of unsuccessful attempts to resolve the matter, and facing language barriers and unfamiliarity with the local legal system, Blake took all three to the Qianhai Cooperation Zone People's Court in Shenzhen.
The dispute became more complicated during the court hearing, as the three defendants presented different accounts of the rental arrangement.
It emerged that Wang, who had signed the lease with Blake, was merely an intermediary holding the property on behalf of others. Li and Zhang were the actual landlords, according to the case details.
However, the three could not agree on who should return the deposit or how the repayment should be divided among them. The disagreement over their respective financial responsibilities threatened to leave Blake without the money he was entitled to recover, despite having completed the property handover and having no fault in the dispute.

The presiding judge identified the central issue: any disagreement among the three defendants over how to divide the financial burden was an internal matter between them. It should not become a reason to withhold the tenant's deposit.
"Their internal disputes can be resolved separately, but their repayment obligations to the tenant must be clear and fulfilled," the judge told the defendants.
The judge then explained the legal responsibilities of each party and pressed the three to put forward a repayment plan during the hearing.
The Outcome
Following the court's mediation, all three defendants eventually agreed to jointly settle Blake's claims, covering the deposit and interest, as well as his legal fees and litigation costs, for a total of ¥20,000.
The agreement was signed, and the three defendants voluntarily paid the full amount the following day.
What Foreign Tenants Can Take From This
Deposit disputes are one of the most common problems foreigners face when renting in China, and this case shows why the paperwork matters more than the handshake. A few habits can save months of trouble:
- Know who actually holds your money. If the person who signs your lease is not the person who receives your deposit, get it in writing — in the contract — who is responsible for returning it.
- Keep every payment record. Bank transfers, receipts and chat messages showing who you paid, how much and when are what a court will ask for.
- Do the handover in writing. A signed move-out checklist with photos protects you against later claims that the flat was damaged.
- Use the local routes first. Community mediation is free, and for smaller amounts the courts offer a relatively simple small-claims process. Language barriers are real, but they do not reduce your legal protections — your rights as a tenant are the same whether you are Chinese or foreign.
Source: OT-Team(G), Qianhai Cooperation Zone People's Court, Shenzhen. Names in this case are pseudonyms as reported. This article is for general information and does not constitute legal advice.
No comments:
Post a Comment